Colin called us in September about a gas power vent water heater that had stopped making hot water entirely. The blower motor on the unit had failed, and the tank behind it was roughly 15 years old.
Colin is a homeowner in Eden Prairie, on the west side of the Twin Cities metro, and his house had never had a water softener installed. When we got to the basement, the old 50-gallon tank was loaded with sediment and the fixtures showed hard water staining. Those two details shaped the whole conversation about what to replace and what to add.
Key Takeaways
- THE CHALLENGEA failed blower motor left a 15-year-old power vent water heater completely out of service, with repair parts harder to source and a repair estimate near $2,500.
- THE INSTALLWe installed a Bradford White 50-gallon power vent water heater with a new mixing valve, plus a first-time Pentair 948 water softener with 48,000-grain capacity.
- THE RESULTTwo technicians finished the water heater, the softener, and an irrigation isolation valve in about four hours, leaving the home with soft water and reliable hot water.
Putting $2,500 of parts and labor into a 15-year-old tank is rarely the right call, so we walked Colin through the repair-versus-replacement chart we present on jobs like this. The math pointed clearly toward replacement. Because the home had no water treatment at all, we also presented a softener as an option to protect the new heater and the rest of the fixtures, and he chose to add it.
Project Summary
| Client Profile: |
Colin, residential homeowner |
| Project Location: |
Eden Prairie, Minnesota (west Twin Cities metro) |
| Primary Objective: |
Restore hot water with a same-visit Tank Water Heater Installation after a blower motor failure |
| System Installed: |
Bradford White 50-gallon power vent heater with a new mixing valve, plus a Pentair 948 48,000-grain Water Softener Installation |
| Key Outcome: |
Soft water and hot water restored in about four hours, with a failing irrigation gate valve replaced |
Why the Old Heater Failed
The blower motor on the power vent heater had quit, and with it the burner. The unit was not producing hot water at all when we arrived, which made the service call urgent rather than optional.
Age and parts availability drove the recommendation. A blower motor replacement on a Bradford White water heater that old, with parts getting harder to source, would have run around $2,500 — a hard number to justify against a new unit with a fresh warranty. Draining the old tank also confirmed what we suspected from the staining on the fixtures: heavy sediment buildup from years of untreated hard water.
Water Heater and Softener Install
Jared and Joe drained down the existing 50-gallon heater, disconnected the PVC venting, gas line, and water lines, and set the new Bradford White 50-gallon power vent unit in place. We added a new mixing valve, which stretches the usable hot water out of the tank and adds a scald margin at older tub and shower valves. That addition tightened up the space above the heater, so a small repipe was needed to route everything cleanly before we reconnected the venting, gas, and water lines.
"Highly recommend Modern Plumbing and Heating! Great customer service. Fast service. Respectful and honest service technicians." - (Samantha, Modern Plumbing & Heating)
With the heater handled, we set the new softener and brine tank near the water main, tied it into the main water lines, ran the discharge hose to the floor drain, completed the start-up procedure, and filled the brine tank with salt. While working near the main, we found an old gate valve on the outdoor irrigation line stuck open and leaking at the stem, so we offered a 3/4-inch ball valve isolation with a drain and Colin approved it. We turned the water back on, filled and fired the new heater, hauled away the old tank, and double-checked our work — the same step-by-step approach we bring to every job across our Plumbing Services and Service Areas.
Adding the mixing valve required a short repipe above the heater so the connections landed properly and looked clean.
Soft Water and Hot Water
Two technicians completed the water heater swap, the first-time softener install, and the irrigation valve replacement in about four hours. Water heaters require permits and inspections in Minnesota cities, so that paperwork was part of the job as well.
Colin reported back that he had soft water and hot water, which is a noticeable day-to-day change in a house that never had treatment. The Pentair 948 we installed regenerates based on gallons used rather than on a fixed clock, so it is not cycling while the family is away, and reducing hardness minerals should help slow the kind of sediment buildup that filled the old tank.
Need a Water Heater Replaced?
We replace tank water heaters and install water softeners across Brooklyn Park, Maple Grove, and the west and northwest metro, and we do enough of them that a combined job like this one typically fits in half a day. We show you the repair-versus-replacement math before anything is approved, and we price the work upfront.
Lost hot water or dealing with hard water in your home? Call us and we will get a technician out to look at it.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a water heater replacement take in Eden Prairie?
Plan on a half day. Most tank water heater replacements run two to four hours, and same-day service is often available. On this job, our two-technician crew handled the heater, a new water softener, and an irrigation isolation valve in about four hours.
Do water heaters require a permit in Minnesota?
Yes. Water heater installations require permits and inspections in Minnesota cities, including Eden Prairie. We handle that process as part of the job so the new unit is documented and inspected.
What warranty comes with a new water heater?
The standard manufacturer warranty is six years, and we can provide in-house warranty coverage up to 12 years. Service life depends heavily on water quality and maintenance — an annual flush and softened water can stretch a tank well beyond the warranty period, sometimes toward 20 years.